Skip links

What is Bill 31, which amends various legislative provisions related to housing?

A bill opposed by landlords for creating too many obstacles to eviction and by tenants for allowing the refusal of lease assignments. How can we make sense of it all?

Before we begin, a little background. This bill was drafted by France-Élaine Duranceau, the Minister responsible for Housing.

The bill introduces three major changes in the form of seven amendments to sections of the Civil Code of Québec and was introduced on June 9, 2023 the last day of the 43rd Legislature, 1st parliamentary session. It will be considered during the next parliamentary session.

Without further ado, let’s look at the amendments that Bill 31 proposes to the provisions of the Civil Code regarding residential leases.

The amendment to Article 1962 of the Civil Code ensures that a tenant who fails to comply with an eviction order within the prescribed time limit is presumed to have refused to vacate the dwelling, as the former article provided for in cases of repossession.

The combined effect of the proposed amendments to Articles 1963, 1965, and 1968 of the Civil Code makes it possible to continue extending the protections afforded in cases of repossession of a dwelling (1963 C.C.Q.) to eviction proceedings and to add further protections, notably by reversing the burden of proof so that the landlord must prove good faith in proceeding with eviction and must pay compensation equal to one month’s rent for each year of lost tenancy, ranging from a minimum of 3 months to a maximum of 24 months’ rent (Article 1965 of the Civil Code of Quebec). Under Article 1968 C.C.Q. as proposed, the tenant will also have the right to seek damages against a landlord acting in bad faith.

Example

Mr. X is a 45-year-old resident living at 595 Saint-Lamarre Street in Montreal. He has fallen behind on his rent by 2 to 5 days for the months of September through November. In December, his landlord sent him an eviction notice, even though there are still 8 years remaining on his lease.

Under current law, the landlord does not need to prove good faith; if he can prove that Mr. X, his tenant, has breached the contract, he can obtain an eviction. Under the new law, the landlord would also have to prove that he is acting in good faith that is, that the eviction is not an indirect attempt to do what he cannot do directly, such as raising the rent and/or finding a more reliable tenant.

With the amendments to Articles 1965 and 1968, even if the court were to grant the eviction, Mr. X would be entitled to compensation for the seven uninterrupted years of lost rental income; thus, under Article 1965, this would amount to seven months’ rent (since only uninterrupted years are counted). Furthermore, if his landlord acts in bad faith, Mr. X could sue his landlord for compensatory or even punitive damages under the amended Article 1968 of the C.C.Q. to compensate for the losses resulting from his eviction and perhaps punish his landlord if the eviction was obtained in bad faith.

Another change is that the legislature intends to repeal Article 1966 of the C.C.Q., which allows the tenant to object to the subdivision, expansion, or change of use of the dwelling.

Tenants are particularly concerned about the latest major change, which would add two sections to the Civil Code: 1978.1 and 1978.2 C.C.Q. These two sections allow a landlord to object to a tenant’s assignment of a lease for a reason other than a “serious cause” as defined in Section 1871 of the current Civil Code. This change regarding lease assignments has been widely discussed; you’ve surely heard about it in the media. Now is the time to understand its nuances—and what better way than with an example!

Example

Ms. Y is the landlord of a 5.5-room apartment in Montreal. Her tenant informs her that he will be raising the rent from $1,800 to $2,200, claiming that he is not subject to the rent guidelines set by the Administrative Housing Tribunal. Ms. Y cannot afford this rent increase because she lives paycheck to paycheck. She therefore decides to post an ad on Facebook to transfer her lease: “Beautiful 5½-room apartment in downtown Montreal, $1,800/month.” She notifies her landlord in accordance with the provisions of Article 1870 of the Civil Code.

Under the current version of Article 1871 of the Civil Code, the landlord may not refuse the assignment without a serious reason (such as the new tenant’s insolvency) and has 15 days to indicate his refusal along with that serious reason; if he fails to do so, he is deemed to have consented to the assignment. With such an assignment, Ms. Y would have to vacate the dwelling but would prevent the landlord from raising the rent for the benefit of the new tenant.

Under the proposed amendments, the landlord could refuse for a reason other than a serious one, for example, because the landlord prefers to select their own tenant and set the terms, such as the rent, themselves. By refusing, the landlord will terminate the lease on the date specified in the notice of assignment sent by the tenant (proposed Art. 1978.2 of the Civil Code).

It is therefore understandable why this amendment is criticized by tenant associations and celebrated by landlord associations.

It is important to remember that this bill is just that a bill introduced on the last day of the last legislative session. It will therefore be reviewed during the next legislative session, and changes may still be made.

If in doubt, it’s best to consult a lawyer. Our attorneys at Boavista Legal Services have extensive experience in cost-effectively defending both tenants and landlords against abusive contracting parties. How? Check out our attorneys’ profiles and our services page to find out.