Skip links

Recent Developments Regarding Commercial Leases During the Pandemic

It goes without saying that the impact the COVID-19 pandemic has had on Quebec’s economy is one of the most significant in modern history.

What practical implications does this have for the future of Quebec businesses, and more specifically for commercial leases?

The obligations of business owners, and particularly those related to commercial leases, are at the very heart of the economic and legal challenges posed by the pandemic.

It is in this context that the judicial system, which by its very nature is constantly evolving, has had to adapt to current market demands.

It is in the context of a dispute between a tenant and a landlord that a force majeure clause takes on its full significance.

“Force majeure” can be defined as an exceptional circumstance, beyond the control of the party experiencing it, that prevents that party from performing the obligations agreed upon in the contract and owed to the other party.

However, even in such cases, the interpretation of what constitutes a force majeure event is far from consistent in case law, and the parties to a commercial lease agreement rarely think to list specific force majeure events or to specify that a pandemic constitutes a circumstance justifying non-performance due to force majeure at least not before the recent onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.

This is precisely what emerges from recent case law on the matter:

In the case of Hengyn International Investment Commerce Inc. v. 9368-7614 Québec Inc. (2020 QCCS 2251), it was held that the obligation to ensure the peaceful enjoyment of the leased premises is an obligation of result.

If the landlord fails to ensure the peaceful enjoyment of the premises, the landlord cannot enforce the tenant’s obligation to pay rent. The government measures ordering the closure of the plaintiff’s gym were, according to the judge, sufficient grounds to constitute a case of force majeure.

However, the judge’s interpretation was not as favorable to the tenant in the case of Lechter (Montreal Professional Building) v. Keurig Canada Inc. (2022 QCCS 1649), where the closure of restaurants due to public health restrictions was not deemed a sufficient reason to exempt the tenant from paying rent to the landlord.

Nor was the landlord obligated to guarantee customer traffic, given the low foot traffic upon the premises’ reopening, contrary to what the tenant had requested.

The same applies in the IT case Côté Coulombe Inc. (I-Tech Solutions) v. Escalade Marketing Inc. (2022 QCCQ 7396), where the judge held that “the fact that the offices had become less useful to the defendant is not the result of a breach of the plaintiff’s obligations.”

It is essential to note, however, that although a contract generally binds the parties to its terms, the Court is not indifferent to the difficult situation faced by business owners during this time of crisis and, in this specific case, has broad discretion to restore the contractual balance if necessary.

Indeed, “(…) the court finds that it is also appropriate to take into account the government’s desire to encourage landlords to show flexibility toward their tenants in order to allow them to save their businesses, in the mutual interest of both parties during these extremely difficult times for everyone.”

Since this is a contentious issue and court decisions may favor one party or the other, it is wise to seek professional advice to ensure you adopt the most appropriate course of action to prevail in court. Boavista Legal Services’ team would be happy to help and provide advice regarding any issues related to your commercial lease!