Introduction: Presentation of fixed-term contracts in Quebec
Fixed-term employment contracts in Quebec establish a contractual relationship between an employer and an employee for a predetermined period of time, either until a fixed date, or until a specific event occurs.
These contracts are frequently used to meet temporary needs, such as for the completion of a specific project or the replacement of an absent employee. Although fixed-term contracts offer advantages for both the employer and the employee, they also have disadvantages for both parties, which should be examined in the context of this article.
Definition and legal framework: Fixed-term contracts and their regulation
In Quebec, a fixed-term employment contract is a contract governed by the Civil Code of Quebec and the Act respecting labour standards (ALS). In addition to the fixed term, the latter differs from the open-ended contract because of the difference in the legal rules that apply to it. For example, did you know that your employer cannot dismiss you without serious cause before the end of your fixed-term contract, at the risk of having to pay you your full salary? To find out more, contact one of our employment lawyers.
You can also visit the website of the Commission des normes, de l’équité, de la santé et de la sécurité du travail (CNESST) to find out about your rights and obligations as an employee or employer.
Employer benefits: Flexibility and cost savings
The fixed-term contract offers employers a great deal of flexibility. They can adjust the amount of their workforce according to their temporary needs, for example, if an employee goes on maternity leave, without a long-term commitment. This illustrates a great saving in costs. It also makes it possible to evaluate an employee before offering him a permanent contract, if necessary.
Disadvantages for employers: Instability and cost of training
A fixed-term contract can be unstable for the employer due to the limited duration of the contract. This means that the company must constantly manage the renewal or replacement of employees at the end of each period, which can disrupt the turnover of work. Of course, at the end of the specific contract, an employer could always decide to hire an employee for a permanent contract if both wish.
As a result, the employer often has to invest in the employee’s training for a limited period of time, which represents an additional cost, with no guarantee that the employee will remain with the company after the end of the contract, making long-term planning of teams and projects more difficult.
Benefits for employees: Access to employment and experience
The fixed-term contract allows an employee to access the job market for a certain period of time, thus offering him or her the opportunity to try out new positions or careers, especially in the event of professional retraining. It also allows them to gain experience, which enriches their resume and increases the chances of accessing desired future opportunities.
Disadvantages for employees on fixed-term contracts: Instability and lack of long-term benefits
Fixed-term contracts can lead to job instability, as there is no guarantee that the fixed-term contract will be renewed or that the fixed-term contract will be converted into a permanent contract. This can create precariousness and uncertainty, without being able to benefit from long-term benefits such as job security, professional development within the company or a salary increase.
Conclusion: The right type of employment contract depends on your company
In conclusion, fixed-term contracts offer flexibility for both employers and employees, by meeting the temporary needs of the company and allowing the employee access to the labour market. However, there are some drawbacks to this process, including instability and lack of long-term security for both the employer and the employee. For employers, these contracts can generate additional costs related to training and renewal management, while for employees, the uncertainty of a lack of long-term prospects can be disadvantageous.
It is therefore essential to carefully assess the various advantages and disadvantages before committing to a fixed-term contract. Our team of lawyers practicing in labour law are committed to guiding you in your decisions.
Book your consultation today with an employment lawyer for personalized advice on choosing and managing your employment contracts!
Release — The purpose of this article is to inform and raise public awareness of legal issues. The legal information in this article is provided for informational purposes only and is likely to vary significantly over time and according to the precise facts of each situation. Reading this article does not create a lawyer-client relationship. This article is not a substitute for a lawyer’s legal opinion and does not engage the liability of Boavista Legal Services Inc., its lawyers, articling students, employees, successors and subcontractors.
